Video: Getting Your I-9s Right: Adapting to New Rules Before an Audit Notice Arrives | Duration: 3469s | Summary: Getting Your I-9s Right: Adapting to New Rules Before an Audit Notice Arrives | Chapters: Welcome & Introduction (0.2799999999999998s), Session Overview (80.11s), I-9 Scoring Rules (262.32499999999993s), I-9 Error Classifications (450.0053791687991s), I-9 Error Framework (663.355s), ICE Policy Changes (772.46s), Substantive Violations (898.4150000000001s), Error Reclassification (1179.1450000000002s), Technical Violations Framework (2068.558067244252s), What Hasn't Changed (2371.759s), Proactive Steps for HR (2737.508507492115s), Solutions and Recap (2904.1040000000003s), Q&A Session (3057.0290000000005s), Closing & Resources (3376.4290000000005s)
Transcript for "Getting Your I-9s Right: Adapting to New Rules Before an Audit Notice Arrives":
Welcome, everyone, to our webinar, getting your I-9's right, adapting to new rules before an audit notice arrives, presented by Paychex and Equifax. My name is Robert Parsons, and I'll be today's host. So if you've been concerned that a prior grace period to correct what used to be considered minor errors on form I-9 has now been replaced with the risk of immediate fines, and you wanna understand how to prepare your business to get ahead of these risks, you're not alone. In the next hour, we're gonna dive into these details, and today's speaker, a form I-9 expert, will offer actionable guidance to help you address these concerns. But before we get started, I just wanna cover some quick housekeeping details. At the right of your console, you'll find the docs column with related resources, including a printable copy of the slide deck we're using today. There's also a live q and a problem I'm sorry, column where you can type in your questions. We have a few team members in the back end helping to provide answers privately. And while we can't guarantee a response to every question, just note that all questions are received and help us create future resources to strengthen your business. I'm hoping we also have time at the end of the event, for some q and a where we can address some of these with our expert right right in front of you. Occasionally, you may also see an audience poll. When the poll opens, a blue alert card will briefly appear at the lower left of your console. Click the button on it or open the poll column at the right. It's gonna be marked with a red dot. To view the poll, there are no wrong answers. Just select your response, click submit, and you'll receive a confirmation message. And finally, please note this presentation does not constitute legal advice. It's for informational purposes only. And now I'd like to introduce today's speaker. As an attorney and technologist, John Fay brings a deep applied knowledge of business immigration, I-9 compliance, and E-Verify rules and procedures. During his twenty year plus career, he has worked closely with corporations, educational institutions, and government agencies on a variety of US immigration and I-9 E-Verify verify issues, often in connection with the use of software and case management technology. He currently serves as director of product strategy for Equifax workforce solutions, which partners with Paychex to provide I-9 services within the Paychex Flex platform. John, welcome, and thank you for joining us today. Why don't you go ahead and take us through your agenda? Yes. Absolutely. Thank you so much, Robert, for that warm introduction. It is really great to be with, all of you today because we have, what I would consider to be a really interesting discussion in store for you about a significant policy change from immigration and customs enforcement that may impact how you evaluate your I-9's both moving forward, and then also just in terms of looking at your existing I-9 records as well. So we have, on here about five different main areas that we're going to cover. So first, what I wanted to do is to give you a little bit of a backgrounder. So it's going to be, okay, how have I-9's actually been classified or view in the past and really what has changed. And we're going to get very granular here. We're going to talk about process level change, form level changes, anything that has come out as, with with respect to this new, policy. Then we're going to shift into what I think will be kind of the most practical element to this, and that is steps that you can take right now in response to this policy guidance to better protect yourself from potential penalties, and fines if you are ever unlucky enough to receive a form I-9 notice of inspection. As Robert mentioned, if we have some time, we'll then do some audience q and a, and then talk about, how our organizations can potentially help you. So a lot to cover here today, but I actually wanna start off with a little bit of a quick story. So the other day, I was actually at a mini, golf course with some friends. I was not playing real golf as this this picture might imply. And at one point, we got to, what some of you might know as the the classic, windmill hole. Right? So, I it was my turn. I hit the ball. The ball hit the blade of the windmill. It bounced back, hit my foot, and then actually rolled into the cup. Now in my head, I'm thinking that's a hole in one. Right? I mean, I and I actually wrote it down accordingly. But, a couple of my my colleagues here with me pointed out that, hitting my foot was a technical penalty. And because I didn't reset the ball correctly, the way I recorded it on the card was now fraudulent, which which I thought was taking it a bit too far. But it reminded me of I I-9's, oddly enough, because when we complete I I-9's, or we even just oversee them at our organization, we always have to think about how they might be scored someday. If Immigration and Customs Enforcement, who many of you may know is is often just referred to by their acronym ICE, if they were to show up and audit your I I-9's. And that scoring process and the rules around it is what we are going to discuss today. But first, I actually wanna hand it back to Robert for our first, poll of the day to, to get a sense of the room. Robert? Thanks, John. And it's a perfect story for this. So we've got a quick poll for you all, and you'll see it in the polls tab to the right and also in that little window in the lower left. So just mark your response and click the submit button. And and the question is, where do you believe most of your I-9 risk currently resides? And you can choose as many as you think are applicable. Is it your old paper and your legacy I I-9's? Is it trying to manage remote I-9 completion? Is it just basic documentation errors, kinda like what John was hinting at there? There's sections one and two. There's a supplement b. I know there's there's a lot of things happening there. Is there issues around work authorization or reverification, or do you really just not know? Do you know there's there's an I-9 form? There's a lot happening, and we're gonna have to to deal with it in some fashion you're hoping to learn more. So as I go through this, John, we got a lot of votes coming in. And, really, I I see that there's there's answers for all of them, but they're really concentrated around what do I do about my paper and legacy I I-9's. And probably hand in hand with that, the documentation errors that might be on those or might be on new ones that I'm doing. How's your how do you react to that? Is that what you're seeing out there in the world as you're working? It is. Yeah. And it makes perfect sense because if you have paper forms, those are forms that probably have all manner of different errors on them, all all different types of issues. And so those are the ones where we can see really some of these types of new error classifications coming into effect. And I'll I'll touch upon that in a little bit. So, thank you all for participating in that poll. We do have a a couple more, so so stay tuned. But I think as we kind of think about what we just saw there and how you all reacted, it really does give us kind of the perfect segue to talk about how the government has historically viewed mistake mistakes over the past forty years. And the first thing I want you really to think about, as you can see here on this slide, is this 1986 foundational, some would say monumental law, which not only created the four I-9 I-9 requirement, but it also introduced the no notion of employer sanctions. So this is the idea that you, as an employer, as an organization, can be held responsible that you can actually be assessed fines and penalties for knowingly hiring unauthorized workers or most notably for our discussion today, failing to properly complete and retain I-I-9 forms. So, again, sticking with our story, after that happened pretty quickly after that law passed, there was also a recognition that this process could become incredibly unforgiving. Right? And I'm sure many of you can can appreciate that. Right? If if we were to treat every single paperwork form mistake, exactly the same way, all of a sudden, you might have, employers with, you know, 95%, error rates. So in 1996, congress actually amended the law. So and they they in doing so, what they did was they they created what is commonly renowned known as the good faith defense. Short story, they often refer to the good faith defense as the Sonny Bono Amendment. For those of you who remember Sonny Bono, aside from being a singer, he also owned, and before he became a senator, he he owned a restaurant. And so when he was in congress, he he actually felt it was very unfair because restaurants were often involved with I-9 audits that employers could be penalized for all of these different types of mistakes. And so when this law was amended, the idea was was fairly practical. Not every clerical or what they referred to as procedural mistake should immediately cause a penalty to be assessed against an employer if they are otherwise acting in good faith. Right? We're we're trying to do our best. We're completing I-9's and oops. We made a mistake. We shouldn't be fine for that. Right? And so that was kind of really the idea. But, of course, you know, once you create that distinction in law and you create a a whole, you know, text around it, the next obvious question becomes, okay. So what's technical and what's not technical or what's more serious? And interestingly, for something that is so important and that has shaped I-9 compliance practices and attorney practices for the last thirty some years, all of that came from what a 1997 memorandum, which is from from the INS general counsel whose names who at the time was Paul Virtue, was mostly most people simply call the Virtue Memorandum. And so if you ever hear that term that's what it refers to. And we're going to talk a little bit more about that in a minute but in essence what has now happened in 2026 is dramatically changing what that error framework looks like. And so let's do a little kinda comparison here on our next slide. So for many, many years, the basic framework for thinking about I-9 errors and mistakes was relatively straightforward. So substantive violations, these are things that are serious, are the types of things that could lead to the hiring of an unauthorized worker. So obviously these types of things the government cares about a lot and so they are things like missing I-9s, missing signatures, entire sections left blank, right? I mean, if if you have I-9's with those types of, problems that could directly impair the government's ability to determine, okay, was this did you actually perform a valid verification? So that's kind of on the on the one hand. On the opposite side, on the right hand side of your slide is what we refer to as technical or procedural violations. And these were those ones that Sonny Bono and others were talking about. They were clerical in nature. They're an address is missing. Maybe a date of birth wasn't entered in the section one. Maybe a field was incomplete, but the overall verification process still occurred. It could be reconstructed. And so that was kind of really the way that we would analyze it. And importantly, employers historically again had an opportunity to correct many of those technical issues before penalties attached. And so as you can imagine over time organizations build processes, audit strategies, remediation protocols, even software, right, around that understanding. Which is why this development that Robert initially mentioned and I've been been talking about as well is getting so much attention. So let's dive right into it and that is the 2026 ICE policy change. So earlier this year, they updated this fact sheet on their website, regarding I-9 audits. And at first glance, it was just like, okay. This is just a if they're just updating the website, well, you know, we'll check it out. We'll see what changes have been made. But as we started reviewing it, we noticed something kind of interesting. So they started listing all of the substantive violations like the ones I just showed you. They started listing the technical. And what we noticed was the substantive list, the ones that are immediately finable or serious, they got much longer. Right? All of a sudden, it seemed very imbalanced where substantive violations are almost anything. And we we looked at it a little bit closely, as we will do in a minute, and what we saw was that what had happened was many of the violations which previously were technical and clerical were now being reclassified. They're being redefined as something that is more serious. And, obviously, that is important to you as employers because, as users and and holders and completers of I I-9's, you can always be subject to a form a I-9 inspection at any time. And, you know, you will obviously want to know, okay, what is our risk if we are audited? What can we do now to help mitigate that type of risk? Another interesting observation just from a high level is that the revised fact sheet now breaks substantive violations apart really more specifically. They talk about section one, section two, the different supplements. They talk about process based, failures that could lead to this. And so what we're gonna do next is actually walk through some of these specific reclassification examples because I think, that's where the practical implications will come into play for you and become essentially more tangible. So let's start with, how really at a higher level. Really, before we get into the field by field examples, I know I know that's where you wanna go because that's what I would wanna do. Tell me the field. But let's start with the high level first. So on the left hand side of this slide you would these are what I would consider the more traditional core substantive violations. And these just to level set with you these are not new. So on the left side, substantive violations include things that like I mentioned, prepare your failure to prepare an I I-9, failure to produce it during an inspection. Maybe you have it but you just don't produce it within the three business days. Failure to complete the form on time, that's timeliness violations. You you may be aware there's timing requirements with sections one, two, and supplement b, or otherwise creating a situation where the government just can't reasonably determine whether you actually verified somebody, right? So these have existed for decades. What is noticeable though is what's on the right hand of the slide. And this shows the revised fact sheet now appears to more explicitly pull certain process based failures into that substantive category, right? And so now you can you kinda can see some of those areas. And one example which I think is notable and we think about all the time is electronic I-9 compliance. Now this concept itself is not new. So the Department of Homeland Security has allowed for electronically generated I-I-9 since dating back to 2006 when they first implemented regulations and they have long maintained that there are a variety of requirements like audit trails, electronic signatures, you know, retrieval capability, record preservation, all this stuff that's in the regulations And and they know that that stuff is important. And so when they review I I-9's, they're they're always looking at all that kind of stuff. So it's not really surprising that they are now stating very clearly that if you have a failure in your electronic I-9 system or your compliance system, that can be a substantive, violation. And, again, it's it's I think it's very important, especially for employers out there who might be using systems or or simple fillable PDFs that were not designed around those regulations. Another item on the slide worth noting is the virtual or alternative procedure. So you you or, other employers might be using this. This is the allowance that came about in 2023. It allows you to remotely examine documents if you're an E-Verify, employer. And so what they're telling us here is that failing to if you do that process and you didn't check the box on the form, that is is now a a substantive violation even though it feels very clear clerical. Right? It's just a checkbox. But from from ICE's perspective, that checkbox is the indicator that you, that you use this. So, you know, again, that's something to to to keep in mind. Similarly, the the revised fact sheet references failure to use, E-Verify, again connected with that, alternative virtual, document review process. And again I think the logic there appears to be tied to the government's framework that you know, hey, you know we're only allowing you to do remote inspection if you're using E-Verify, if you're not using E-Verify well that's a problem. So you know, again this these are things we expected the government to do but now they're more clearly, specifying it in this revised guidance. Another process based failure which, has changed here is this the Spanish language form I-9 outside of Puerto Rico. So you may be aware that the government produces a Spanish version of the form I I-9. It can be used for translation purposes, in the Continental US but it can only be retained in its Spanish form, like, the actual original form in Puerto Rico. Previously, they considered this one of these clerical errors, but now it is substantive as well. So, again, high level, when you take a step back and you look at all of these examples together, to me, the broader pattern, you know, really is that ICE appears to be applying a narrower interpretation, of what qualifies as merely technical and a broader interpretation of what may materially affect the integrity of that verification process. And we haven't even gotten into the individual fields yet. So let's actually start to do that now, and you'll put all the pieces together. So here is the section one reclassification. And what I've done on this slide is to highlight the specific section one fields that ICE now appears to classify as substantive when missing. And I'll say this again, when I say that the reason the reason you would care is because if you have a failure, it could be immediately fined. Right? You wouldn't even get an opportunity to correct, if the government actually shows up and and asks for your I I-9. And some of these, I think, are actually fairly striking when you compare them against what what has been done in the past. So let let's take the one that gets, I think, the most attention, date of birth. So, traditionally, most people would not have viewed a missing date of birth as the kind of a mission that, you know, undermines the verification process. Is it important? Absolutely. Is it helpful for identity matching and record integrity? Yes. Absolutely. But historically, that would have felt much more like a clerical issue for many of us rather than the type of violation that immediately triggers a fine. So the fact that it now appears here in the substantive category really kind of illustrates that narrow review, and I think it also validates what many of you chose in the poll. Right? Because paper I I-9's, electronic I-9's for the most part, they're not gonna let you skip past. They're not gonna let the employees skip past the date of birth. They're gonna have to enter something. Paper, you know, it's the wild, wild west. You you can wind up with all kinds of things, including missing dates of birth. The other really important change here, I think, is involves some of the employee identification numbers that are associated with non citizen workers. So if you ever have somebody who checks that fourth box, alien authorized to work, this is where this comes into play. And in the past, again, this was one of those things that was that was there was a lot of flexibility, and now there's much less. So, let's give an example. So you have somebody, let's say this box four, and they're supposed to provide you with their alien number, also known as an a number, or an I 94 number or foreign passport information. In the past, if that information was missing, but you had a copy of the document with it on on there, they would treat that as a technical violation. But the revised policy appears to move away from that approach. It doesn't mention copies at all. And so that, you know, essentially suggests that some of these omissions may be treated now as a serious violation regardless of what your document copy policy is. We will talk a little bit more about document copies in just a minute. But moving on, I think the missing employee signature date is also an interesting one. One. So this this again shows up a lot on paper. Right? You might have had a I-9 I-9. It's perfectly executed. Everything was done on time, but it's missing it's missing a date. And in the past, in recent past anyway, ICE would often, you know, just to classify that as a technical violation. But now, once again, it's in this substantive immediately finable category. So I think when you look at all of these section one examples, you know, altogether, you know, the broader message again is that ICE appears to be viewing missing information as material information really to to a large degree. So that's section one. That's the one that the employee completes. Now let's actually move on to section two. And this is the one that you or in some instances, an authorized representative will complete. This is where the documents are recorded. This is where the the actual employment information, employer information is recorded. And again, you'll you'll notice the theme, right? So I've highlighted the specific fields that now, are substantive when missing. And for many employers, I would say, especially those that have dealt with large volumes of paper or legacy, some of these examples are gonna feel very familiar. Right? I mean, you you you have a situation where it's clear that maybe okay. I know we reviewed documents. Right? I know that they gave a drivers and a social. I know I know that happened, but oops, we didn't enter an issuing authority. Oh, they forgot to enter the document number. Everything else is there but those those fields. And historically, if you had a copy of the document and ICE shows up, they would classify that as technical, meaning you can correct it. The the Sonny Bono amendment applies. You can correct it within ten ten days. Hooray. That's great. Right? Now, there's no mention of, of this at all. So regardless of whether or not you have a copy of the document according to their policy, they can now assess, assess a substantive violation, and a fine. Right? And so, you know, I think that is, you know, a big one to be to be aware of. Another one here, which is often problematic again on paper forms is the first day of employment. They've they've improved it with the form design. But for many years, the, first day of employment, it was literally in the middle of a paragraph. I mean, it was so easy to miss when you're completing it on paper. And in the past, that was considered a technical violation, but now it it is considered a substantive. We also see the alternative procedure checkbox here, which I was, just mentioning, a few, minutes ago. But one of the most important additions on this slide that I wanna highlight is the receipt rule language. So first a little review. Under the receipt rule, you all as employers can sometimes accept a temporary document in place of the actual document. Typically in situations involving a lost, stolen, or damaged document, right? So somebody shows up says, oh, I lost my Social Security card, my dog ate it. Whatever the case may be, if they've actually applied for a replacement and they have a receipt of that transaction, they can show it to you and that allows you to employ the individual, they can start work, you can pay them for a period of up to I-9ty days and then they have to provide, replacement, documentation. This revised fact sheet now explicitly states that failure to follow-up. So in other words, you completed an I I-9, there's a receipt, you have this I-9ty day window, but you don't follow-up. And we've seen this time and time again because sometimes there's this thought that, oh, the I-9's a one and done. I don't have to do anything with it once I complete it. While that may be the case for many employees, it's not always the case, right? So, I think that's one where again we have to think about okay, what does our process look like? Is this a potential gap? Is this something that we need to be, concerned about? So that's section two. Now, let's, go into can just interrupt. real quick, Please. a lot of detail here, a lot of information. I just wanna remind. our audience, you can download a copy of this deck so you can really see in detail all this great content that John is providing. And we'll also be sending out a recording of the event so you can watch again and take your time and go through, you know, when it's more convenient to you, really make sure you have a handle on this because John's really getting into the nitty gritty, which I really appreciate. So I just wanna make sure you all know that we'll have these for you, so you can really do this correctly and really understand what's happening here. And now back to you, John. Just wanna make sure everybody knew that. No. I appreciate that, Robert. Yeah. And that's it's a great call out because, you know, this stuff can get very highly technical, not to use not to use a term that I've been using, but but it can be very difficult to to analyze. And so, definitely take take your time in looking through it and of course we are available for questions. So let's move on to another part of the form, which again has potential changes. Now I will note that this part of the form is called supplement a. It is the preparer and translator certification. It is not used a terribly a lot because really what it is is if your employee needs assistance with completing section one or maybe they need some translation of the fields and you or somebody else helps them, the government requires you to complete this supplement a, portion. It used to actually be just part of section one, the very bottom, but more recently they separated it out. So now it's called supplement a. And what I would note here is historically, again, omissions in this area in the prepared translator area were generally viewed again technical, procedural, minor. And I think that made a lot of practical sense, right? I mean, in many situations, the government can still tell that somebody assisted with this form because maybe a portion of the certification is completed. You know, a box was checked. Maybe some information was provided, but not all of it was provided. But once again, kinda continuing our theme of, you know, 100% compliance, under this revised sheet, now any omission in this field, if it applies, if you actually used a preparer or a translator, now is categorized as a substantive violation. And it just again, this is just adding to the things that you need to check potentially with your current I-9 records or with your procedure moving forward. If, for example, you you find you have a lot of these. For for example, maybe you have a lot of workforce who, English is not their first language, you might have, for example, more of these types of issues, that you would need to review. So that's supplement a. And then our our last kind of form section to cover, which is used a little bit more, is supplement b. As many of you probably know, this can be used for, the way I like to refer to it is three different purposes. So, one of the most common scenarios is for reverification of temporary work authorization. So you have somebody who checks that fourth box in section one. They're here on a temporary basis. They have temporary work authorization. Before that work authorization expires, if if the employee is still employed with you, you're required to reverify them, make sure they have additional or continuing work authorization. Sometimes in limited circumstances, it can even be used for lawful permanent residents who provide temporary green card documents. So that's one use of supplement b. Another use is for rehires. So if you're rehiring somebody within three years of when you originally completed the I I-9, the government allows you to use kind of a a little short section. The employee doesn't need to enter anything. You just complete, the the the rehire date and any name changes or or, status changes on that form. And finally, it can also be used by many organizations for legal name changes. So you have somebody who changes their name, did a marriage, divorce, or other reason, the government recommends, doesn't necessarily require, but they recommend that you complete it in supplement b. So those are those are the reasons, that you might complete it. And what we're seeing here, not surprisingly, is that ICE is applying many of those same substantive violation concepts that we just discussed for section two. So if supplement b is being used for a rehire and that rehire date is missing, just like the date of hire in section two, that is now gonna be classified as a substantive or serious violation. Also, if supplement b is being used for that reverification, that temporary worker, and you've got required document details, document number, document expiration date is missing, That is also a substantive violation as well. And just like we discussed before, it doesn't appear to preserve the the carve out for employers who had main maintained document copies. So in the past, like I said, you have a document copy. It has that, you know, missing document information on it. That means it becomes technical. That, kind of safety net appears to be gone based on the way this this guidance is now looking at. And then we also see the missing alternative procedure checkbox. Again, if you're you're examining documents remotely, for for reverification. So the tightening of the rules, I think, I think we've demonstrated, seem to apply across initial verification, reverification and rehire workflows. So to Robert's point, we have mentioned a lot here. And so I thought at this point it might actually be a good time to see if we can do a pop quiz. Now, Robert, I know nobody likes a pop quiz but we're gonna make this fun because it doesn't, your answer doesn't matter. It's all, nobody knows. We're not holding you accountable. The government is not here. So this is just a way of testing your knowledge. So go ahead, Robert. Alright. So we've got a quick it's a poll, but it's really a quiz for you. You'll see it once again, though, in the poll tab to the right and also with that little panel on the lower left. So go ahead and mark your response and click the submit button. Which of the following is now a substantive violation? You can only choose one. So I-9 completed on wrong edition, a missing address in section one, a missing first date of employment in section two, E-Verify case received a final nonconfirmation, or an incorrect date format. So what is a substantifile? I think people have been paying attention here, John. I think it. you're right. like it a lot. This is very good. That missing first date of employment in section two, nearly 90% of our attendees, got that one correct. That's excellent. Great job everyone. Thank you for participating. So now that we've basically gone through some of those kind of foundational elements relating to substantive violations, and it seems like the vast majority of you, were following along which is great. But even if you you guessed incorrectly, don't worry about it. Again, to Robert point. It's a lot of material. It's a lot of information. Check out the deck afterwards and and hopefully it will it will start to click. But again, moving on so far what we have discussed in our our time together today have been situations where violations that were historically viewed maybe as clerical or technical were being recategorized, right, as substantive. But there's something else that you should know about the revised ICE policy and that it is also identify several newly articulated technical violations as well. And I think these are actually pretty interesting because they seem to fall into two broader themes that we've put here on this slide. Identity integrity and program integrity. So let's start with the identity focused items first. And one of the the newly listed technical violations is failure to record other last names used by the employee. So this is in section one and to a large degree, I would say this is not a huge surprise. So if you've been doing I-9's for a while, you might remember that years ago, the form specifically asked for maiden name and under the historical guidance, omissions of a maiden name were already generally treated as a technical error. So in other words, it's an error but you can fix it. Over time, the form broaden that concept into other last names used, which obviously captures more than just marriage related name changes. So this, you know, I think feels less like a dramatic policy shift and more more just terminology ice modernizing the terminology around an already familiar concept. So that's okay. But from a practical standpoint, I think it's still important because if you're, you know, conducting some sort of cleanup or remediation effort, that field is now specifically identified in this revised guidance. Right? So it is something to keep in mind. We also see a new technical violation involving failure recorded employees updated name in supplement b. So that's for, you know, for the rehires or even reverifications. And so again, something to keep in mind. And then there's another one that really feels very paper world specific, and that's failure to include the employee's complete name at the top of page two, supplement a or supplement b. So, you know, they have this field on and and for a while they did on on these forms, where they where they have the name at the top. And really what it is about is it's just in the paper world, if they were to ever get separated, that would be a problem. Right? Because then you wouldn't necessarily know what this form or what this page belongs to if there's no name at the top. So, but again, you know, just something to to be aware. So that's that's our one category. Now let's look at program integrity. And the first example is failure to use the correct edition of the four I-9 I-9. So we just had that on our last poll question as as kind of a a decoy there. But this one widely operationally understood as being a technical violation. By the way, the way you fix this, there's a couple different ways. You can typically just attach an explanation to the form that was completed on the wrong version, just noting that it was filled out, in good faith incorrectly. And that that's okay as long as the the documents were acceptable at that time. You can do it that way. You can also just, complete the the top portion, the name portion of, the the new form, the form that it should have been completed on and attach it. I personally, I like just attaching a note that explains it. And so that's, you know, how you would deal with that. It's still technical. A really interesting one to me though is that second one there involves social security numbers for E-Verify for participants. And so basically what they're saying here is if you're using E-Verify, it's now considered a technical violation if the Social Security number that was recorded on the I-9 was actually, incorrect, which is is a little bit problematic, in a way because as employers, we are instructed that we are not supposed to validate information in section one. So we're not supposed to ask to see a social security card for example, if an employee writes it. Right? The employer employee can present whatever they want. But, you know, this kind of now implies that employers might be held accountable if that information, is a mismatch, if it is incorrect. And so it kind of just raises the stakes, especially if you're using electronic systems to try to to make sure that you can keep that information, in sync. So, but importantly, and I think this is a good reminder before we move on, these are, again, are all technical violations. Right? So which means in the event of an audit, you will be given generally an opportunity to correct. You get 10 before any penalties may be assessed. So we don't need to go crazy over these, but they are important to know. So now we're gonna shift gears and I think getting a little bit more of the practical stuff. So we've we've talked about reclassifications. We've talked about new substantive violations. We've talked about increasing exposure, increasing scrutiny, and this is probably I think the right moment to say what hasn't changed, right? And I view this section as a little bit of the silver lining, in what might otherwise appear as a very heavy conversation. Despite all of the changes that we just walked through, the underlying good faith remediation framework that's in the statute still matters, right? So these are long standing concepts involving remediation, mitigation, good faith efforts, regardless of what ICE puts up on a website, all of those concepts still exist. And I think that's really important to remember because otherwise I think there might be a tendency and we've actually even seen it where somebody looks at this and says well well gee if everything is a substantive violation what's the value in correcting anything? And the answer is potentially quite a bit. So let me go through that with you. So first, there's the practical and legal concept of good faith. So the statute, it references it multiple times and historically, both ICE and the courts have recognized a meaningful distinction between employers that proactively review and correct errors versus employers that simply, you know, ignore the issues altogether, kind of just throw up their hands. So practically speaking, when an employer voluntarily conducts, for example, internal audits, reviews records, spends time and resources correcting deficiencies, you know, maybe updates processes, retrain staff, all the things that you all do with I-9's and and many other areas. When you take that effort, that creates a very different narrative than an employer that made no effort whatsoever to correct their I I-9's. And historically, again, what we've seen is ICE has repeatedly indicated that employers are encouraged to make corrections before an inspection, occurs. So again, something to keep in mind. And if you take a step back again, I think it it really makes sense because ICE is generally far more concerned about employers that appear indifferent to the verification process than employers that are actively trying to identify and remediate problems. The second point on this slide I'll make quickly is mitigation. So even let's say, you know, you have a substantive violation, ICE decides to fine you on it, under the statute again, if you've taken good faith efforts, you can qualify for a percentage mitigation of the fine. Sometimes it can only be 5%, but that's okay. It's still any kind of mitigation is generally a good thing. And finally, the last thing I wanna mention here, which can be huge, is the five year statute of limitations. Not many people know this, but there is a five year statute of limitations that generally applies in this area. But there's a catch. It only works if it actually starts running the five years until it doesn't work until you correct the I I-9. So if you have an I-9 and it has issues and you just leave it, you can be fine for it. But if you take steps, you make corrections, then the five year period starts. And then, you know, post five years, if you're audited, you would then potentially have a defense to a fine or penalty. So again, huge advantage for employers that take things into their own hands. So again, when you put all this together, I think the year is not, alright, there's nothing we can do. Right? Everything is substantive. The takeaway that I hope you you take from this is that proactive correction efforts can still carry, a lot of value even within this revised enforcement environment. And with that, Robert, I think it is time for another pop quiz. Sorry. Apparently, one one compliance quiz during webinar was not enough. Go ahead. Will do. And and thank you, John. Boy, the devil certainly is in the details, isn't it, here? Alright. So you'll see that tab opening again, and the button just mark your response and click the submit. Which of the following is a new technical violation? I've seen some questions come in around these two. A missing date of birth in section one, missing document information in section two, a late completed I I-9, or missing audit trails, or incorrect Social Security number did it make it there? I can't see that one. Unfortunately, it didn't make it there. And as it turns out, that is the correct answer. That is see, we that's a really misleading poll right there. I don't see is because. I was suspicious. I thought I might have got that one right, actually. Right. But, you know, can you tell me a little bit about the missing date of birth in section one, John? And I and I. know we we've only got fifteen minutes left, but there were some questions about missing dates versus wrong dates. Mhmm. Just want a little clarity on that real quick. There's not too much time, but a little clarity on that. Yeah. Absolutely. So, the inclusion of that in this poll here was a little bit of of red herring. So under the new revised guidance, a missing missing, not not incorrect, missing date of birth is a substantive violation, meaning you could be immediately fine. The way the policy guidance is written, most of these things refer to omissions as opposed to incorrect. The one example that that where it does say incorrect, is that Social Security number, but that's a technical violation. And so that's why we feel as though the paper forms where where you can have a lot of missing stuff are the are the biggest, risk. Very good. Thank you. Yeah. Absolutely. So we are in the home stretch here. And so let's go through, very quickly so then we can take some additional questions. So these, again, I think are some things that you might consider, hopefully, practical, hopefully actionable to do, with all this information. And what I would say, just kinda highlight from a broad perspective, is there's no single universal I-9 strategy that I think works the same for everybody. Right? Every employer is different. You all have your own hiring models, HR systems, staffing levels. You have your own risk tolerance. Right? And so, you know, we look at some of these, these are again I think the things to consider. And the first is focusing on the areas that may present the greatest exposure. This has always been a good idea in the I-9 world, but you know for for many employers I think like we've said paper legacy I-9's have a significant concentration of risk because you have omissions, missing dates, missing document details, missing start dates, incomplete fields. And remember, you might be using an electronic solution now, but you might still have paper for some of your long standing employees. The those paper might now have a lot of risk, associated with them. So from a practical standpoint, you might want to start identifying, right, where are those where are those paper forms? Do we have them? Have we reviewed them before? Those types of things. The second area, again, I usually recommend reviewing your workflows. Right? I think this becomes especially important around remote verification if you're using that virtual process or if you're dealing with receipts, right, because those are those are now, process based, potential failures. In addition to that, I think the third area I would mention briefly is prioritization, right? Not every issue carries the same level exposure. So if you've got missing I I-9's, you've got reverification failures, if you have doubts about your current electronic I-9 solution, maybe it doesn't have audit trails, maybe maybe you're just using fillable PDFs. Again, those are now under the radar, with this new, policy, change. So again, you know, finally I think if employers are conducting remediation efforts, consistency and documentation become very important in this process, right? Track what was reviewed, track what's corrected, track your decision making and apply your remediation approaches consistently across the organization. And with that, I'll now hand it back to Robert. Thank you, John. It really does sound like there's two layers here. There's a there's that layer of of being being buttoned up and handling new intake forms correctly and handling I-9 correctly. But then there's that looking back and making sure you you don't have a history of problems. So I can see that, you know, our audience really needed to address those separately. So I wanna dive into this for a quick moment, then we'll get into some q and a where Paychex does offer an form I-9 task as part of the new hire process. And there's even an option for remote form I-9 completion for a fee, and that's available through our partnership with Equifax. So those of you who are existing Paychex clients, you already have access to this within the Flex platform. And if you're an eight if you're a Paychex client with an HR business partner, we encourage you to reach out to them for support. If you're currently a Paychex client and wanna learn more about how a day dedicated HR VP can help you address compliance concerns like this, we encourage you to click yes on the next poll, and we'll we'll reach out to you and explore how Paychex can help you take advantage of this. You can also click the talk with our team button up there on the top of your screen, that white button, and we'll have somebody follow-up with you. As John Fay mentioned, every business situation is is different, and one strategy does not fit all. So we'd really like to to discuss what's gonna work best for you. So I wanna just recap quickly what we covered today. You know, we talked about some of the history around I-9's and what happened before till we got to today. We talked about what the new substantive violations are for, what's going on there. We talked about, how to how to handle process versus how to handle those technical issues. And then finally, we talked about how Equifax and Paychex can help you. So, you know, we can go to a quick poll. This is the final one. Just mark your response and click submit if you'd like to speak to a Paychex expert about getting some of that dedicated HR guidance and compliance support to help your business navigate these changes. It really is, it's complicated, but I think and, John, I think you reiterated this. Once you have your processes in place, once you know what you're doing, it's actually still very straightforward. It's still very manageable. It's just a matter of of crossing the t's and dotting the i's, and handling this appropriately. So if you'd like somebody to help you get that set up, just go ahead and click yes there. And now, I wanna get to some Q&A Now I do have a producer on the back end who was gonna launch a survey near the close of the Q&A It may block some of your ability to ask questions, but please go ahead and enter them. We just wanna find out how we're doing today and how useful this topic is for you. So now let's grab some of those questions, that you've submitted. And this first one here comes from Rachel, and she wants to know, do you think ICE is likely to actually enforce these newer substantive classifications aggressively, or is this really, you know, kind of this back office? They're just positioning things within the fact sheet, and they're just really trying to get their ducks in a row. Or is this are we gonna see this in the field, in the future? Yeah. And I think that's a great question, Rachel. And and I think the the the honest answer right now is we we don't fully know yet. This is still kind of relatively new. The the policy was was announced in March. I think what we do know is that the revised ice policy gives us important insight into how ice is viewing these violations operationally. And I think that matters because those classifications can influence how the I-9 inspections are conducted. So you may or may not know this, but every single I-9 audit is different. You every, you know, there's a different special agent in charge. If you look across the country where you get audited, your experience may be different. And so anytime they they do something from kind of like a headquarter perspective, a policy perspective, we as practitioners and and and in HR, we we pay attention to it because it's generally signaling. It's saying, okay, you know, maybe they won't follow this to the letter. Maybe they will still provide some leniency as they have historically done. But clearly, they want employers to know that there's an expectation that this form is completed right the first time around. And so again, I think that's just helpful as we prepare our own, you know, policies as we think about how we might do cleanup of our I-9's and those sorts of things. Excellent. Okay. And this one came in from Jeffrey. This is I think came up when I was talking about, okay. There's getting your process ready going forward, but then there's that look back. And Jeffrey asks, if an employer identifies newly substantive errors during an internal audit, would you generally recommend correcting them now even though they already may be finable? Yeah. And that it's another really good practical question. And I would say, generally speaking, yes. Because in many situations, I think remediation, right, it still makes sense. The the reasons behind it, you get good faith correct correction efforts that you can present to the government. The, ICE and courts have historically distinguished between employers who proactively identify and those who who don't do anything. I mean, it's just it's almost psychological in a way because if you if you have if you're audited and you have you show them exactly what we've what you've corrected, you've got memos attached to everything versus some employer that didn't do anything, They're gonna say well, let's let this guy go and go down the street and go after this other one. I mean that that's just what we've seen many many times happen. So we think that there's still a great deal of value in claiming that good faith remediation. I I like that, and I really like it's you can't just claim good faith. You have to demonstrate it. So that. really that really proves your point. Now there's a we've had a lot of clients that have have been with us a long time. They're family businesses. The businesses have been around a long time, and they're gonna have older I-9's for employees that were hired many years ago. Should they be concerned? I mean, no. It's you you talked a little bit about paper versus electronic and and so I just you know, maybe this will be our last question because we're coming up on time. But how do I handle the the past versus the present? Yeah. And again, very, very good practical question. And I think, you know, pay paper and legacy I-9 populations, I think they deserve thoughtful attention, maybe not panic. Right? Simply because paper forms are more vulnerable to human omission. And as we've kinda talked about today, a lot of these policies are looking at omissions of these fields. So from a risk prioritization standpoint, given given that supposition, I think many employers, would benefit by start evaluating where they have large concentrations of older paper I-9's for current employees, whether, you know, figuring out whether those populations contains any kind of patterns of, you know, these substantive violations. You can look through our sides. You can see them all. You can go to the go to the website. You can see them there too. But again, this doesn't necessarily mean every employer, you know, suddenly, you know, we'd we'd need a massive emergency remediation project tomorrow. It just means that you should be thoughtful, strategic, and and really just kind of plan out how you identify your greatest potential exposure. Excellent. Thank you, John. And thank you all for all those great questions. We're coming up on time here. I just I do want to point out that we do have a lot of resources related to today's topic. It's in the docs column at the right side of your screen there and a printable PDF of the slide deck. We've got a handy FAQ sheet with multiple links to government resources, including some of those that are cited in this list. There's also handouts on our form I-9 and E-Verify service and more. So just about about how you can organize a self audit, make sure your your documents are up to spec, all of that. You can also, follow John on LinkedIn via his link in the slide deck. He's always got great posts and great information for you. We'll be sending a follow-up email to all registrants with a link to the recording and the related resources. You can share it, with people who could use this information. And with that, I'm gonna thank you all for joining us for getting your I-9's right today. If you haven't yet completed the brief survey that launched previously, we encourage you to finish that up now before we close. We really value and appreciate your feedback. We're really trying to bring value to you, and your response helps us improve future resources like this to support your business. And, of course, if you'd like to review the needs of your business with a Paychex expert, just click that talk with our team button at the upper right, and we'll get a free consultation. Someone will reach out to you and talk about your specific needs. Thanks again for joining us today, and I hope you all have a great, great day. Thank you all.