Video: Preventing Penalty Risks: Preparing Your Clients for New I-9 Error Rules | Duration: 3453s | Summary: Preventing Penalty Risks: Preparing Your Clients for New I-9 Error Rules | Chapters: Webinar Introduction (0.2799999999999998s), Housekeeping and Setup (43.655s), Speaker Introduction (137.89999999999998s), Session Overview (187.14499999999995s), I-9 Error Framework (373.95s), Technical vs Substantive Violations (495.75s), Substantive Violations Framework (816.66s), Section Auditing Requirements (1239.2389999999998s), Supplement A & B (1665.6539999999995s), Technical Violations (1882.3839999999996s), Good Faith Remediation (2283.9529999999995s), Form I-9 Technical Violations (2648.0279999999993s), Actionable I-9 Strategy (2697.9929999999995s), Closing and Resources (2971.282999999999s)
Transcript for "Preventing Penalty Risks: Preparing Your Clients for New I-9 Error Rules": Welcome everyone to today's CPE webinar, Preventing Penalty Risks, Preparing Your Clients for New I-nine Error Rules, co presented by Paychex and Equifax. My name is Robert Parsons, and I'll be today's host. Now there used to be a grace period to correct what was considered minor errors on a form I nine. That has now been replaced with the risk of immediate fines. As your client's trusted advisor, you'll want to understand how to prepare your clients to get ahead of these risks. So in the next hour, we're gonna dive into the details, and today's speaker, a Form I nine expert, will offer actionable guidance to help you address these concerns for your clients. Now before we get started, let's cover some quick housekeeping details. At the right side of your console, you'll find a docs column, and I'll have related resources, including a printable copy of the slide deck. And then we'll also have a q and a column right next to that where you can type in your questions. Now we have a few team members in the back end helping to provide answers, and they're doing that privately. Now we can't guarantee a response to every question, but note that all questions are received. They do help us create future resources to strengthen your business. And I'm hoping towards the end, we do have some time for some live q and a. Now occasionally, in fact, probably, in fact, definitely, you'll see an audience poll. Now when a poll opens, a blue alert card will briefly appear at the lower left of your console. Just click the button on it or open the poll column at the right. It'll come up with a little red dot to view the poll. Now there are no wrong answers. Just select your response, click submit, and you'll receive a confirmation message. So to earn CPE credit today, you must respond to three of four polls and remain connected for at least fifty minutes. Now provided you meet both those requirements, you'll receive a separate email within a few hours after the close of the session to download your CPE certificate. Now if you don't meet the requirements, you won't receive an email. So please note on demand recordings also, they're not eligible for CPE. And finally, I wanna note that this presentation does not constitute legal advice. This is for informational purposes only. And now I'd like to introduce today's speaker. As an attorney and technologist, John Fay brings a deep applied knowledge of business immigration, I nine compliance, and E Verify rules and procedures. During his twenty plus year career, he has worked closely with corporations, educational institutions, and government agencies on a variety of US immigration and I-nine and E Verify issues, often in connection with the use of software and case management technology. Now he currently serves as director of product strategy for Equifax Workforce Solutions, which partners with Paychex to provide form I nine services within our Paychex Flex platform. John, welcome, and thank you for joining us today. And why don't you take us through today's agenda real quick? Tell everybody what we'll be covering. Absolutely. And thank you, very much, Robert, for that warm welcome. It is my pleasure, to be with all of you here today. And we have a really interesting discussion in store for you because we're going to talk about a significant policy change from immigration and customs enforcement, also known as ICE, that occurred earlier this year, which may impact how your clients evaluate I nines and ultimately assess risk at their organizations. So before I get ahead of myself, which tends to happen, I'll give you a sense of where we're heading today. So first, we are going to spend some time on what's changed when it comes to how I nines are being classified. And in doing so, we're gonna take a look at how the government has historically treated I nine mistakes and why that matters today. Then we'll shift into what hasn't changed because even with all of the attention around this new policy shift, the underlying good faith framework for correcting I nines still exists, and it's very important to consider as you help your clients evaluate their own risk. And then lastly, we're going to explore some practical steps that employers can take in light of this policy change. So jam packed session for sure. But before we get started, I wanna start actually with a very quick, story to help put today's presentation in perspective. So the other day, I was at a a mini golf course, with some friends, not playing real golf as this picture might imply. And at one point, we got to the classic, windmill hole if you're familiar with it. Now, my friend had a terrible start, to this hole so I was I was really bearing down here and I, I struck the ball cleanly, but it hit that windmill blade as it was going around. The ball bounced back, hit my foot, which I don't remember, and then it rolled into the cup. So in my head, I'm thinking that's a hole in one if ever I add one, and I wrote it down accordingly. But my friend pointed out that hitting my foot was a technical penalty, and because I didn't reset the ball correctly, the way I recorded it on the card was now fraudulent, which I I think was taking it a little bit too far, but it reminded me, of I nines and audits because, you know, occupational hazard. Because when we complete I nines as employers or we help clients review them for sufficiency, we always have to think about how they might be scored, right, someday if immigration and customs enforcement, ICE, were to show up and audit them. And that scoring process and the rules around it appear to have changed as we are going to discuss in some detail today. But before we do, I will hand it back to Robert for our first polling question. Thanks, John. That's a that's a competitive friend you got there. Alright. So let's. get to our first our first poll question right here. And you should see the polls tab opening to the right of your console, and you'll see that blue, alert, tab coming up on the lower left. So go ahead, mark your response, and click the submit button. So under the traditional I nine error framework, how much time must an employer generally be given to correct a technical violation? Is it twenty four hours? Is it at least ten business days? Is it thirty calendar days? Or is it before the office printer runs out of toner? And it's it's really just trying to get a feel now. There was a traditional error framework. There was time to correct those errors. Now that we're starting to get into some nitty gritty, but it... You you know, as John will explain, there is a lot of nitty gritty, a lot of detail, a lot of opportunity for you to advise your clients on just all the stuff they have to keep track of. So in traditional I nine error framework, how much time must an employer generally be given to correct a technical violation? Twenty four hours, ten business days, thirty calendar days, or d, before the office printer runs out of toner? And let's see now. We've got just a few votes around twenty four hours. And we got a few votes around the office printer, but it looks like the consensus amongst our audience is at least ten business days or thirty calendar days. I'm gonna take my guess, John. I would say at least ten business days. What... How did I do there? You did. You did very well. That is the traditional framework, which we're we're gonna discuss. So very good and very good to all of you that selected that. So now thank you all for for for participating in that. And that I think provides us with a good segue to talk about really the framework behind all this that really actually spans back, believe it or not, for forty years. So the first thing I want you to to really think about from this slide is this 1986 foundation, some would even say monumental law known as the immigration reform and control act, which not only created the 499 requirement but also introduced the notion of employer sanctions. And so what that means is your clients' employers can be held responsible and can be assessed fines and penalties for knowingly hiring and continuing to employ unauthorized workers, that's one element to it, and for failing to properly complete and retain I nine forms. That's the part that we're really gonna hone in on today. So history history lesson continues. Pretty quickly after that law passed, there was also this recognition that this process could become incredibly unforgiving, really, if every single mistake on a form I nine was treated the exact same way. And if you think about, you know, the volume of I nines involved for, you know, many organizations, that certainly makes sense. Right? You're talking about humans completing forms. Often it's HR teams. Maybe they're onboarding employees quickly. You know, back in the day you had handwritten documents. You know often you'll find decentralized hiring locations and you know mistakes are inevitable. I think we can all agree on that. So then in 1996 congress amended the law to rate to what we commonly refer to, to include the good faith defense. And the basic idea behind this was fairly practical so that not every clerical or procedural mistake should immediately trigger a penalty if an employer is otherwise acting in good faith and the issue can be corrected. So in other words, there needs to be some distinction between an error that was administrative in nature versus something that perhaps fundamentally undermines the entire verification process itself. But, of course, once you, you know, create that distinction by law, the next obvious question becomes, alright, so what counts as technical and what counts as not technical? And interestingly for something that has really shaped, I nine compliance practices and and really employer practices for nearly three decades, decades, a huge amount of that interpretation traces back to a 1997 memorandum from then ins general counsel Paul Virtu, which we simply refer to as the Virtu memorandum. That's the third item on the slide, and that became incredibly influential because it created the framework, that you might be familiar with. So we have technical violations and we have substantive violations. So before I describe what's changing or what has changed in 2026, I want to do a really quick kind of level set on what this traditional framework actually looks like. So, this is the traditional framework and, basically the way the virtue memorandum set it up is you've got substantive violations and technical. Substantive violations are viewed as the serious stuff. So this is... Imagine you are auditing a client and you find, excuse me, missing I nines, meaning you have somebody on the payroll, no I nine. Maybe you find an I nine where it was completed, but you're missing signatures. Or you see another one where an entire section was left, incomplete. These are failures that the government feels like really just impairs impairs the entire process. How can I tell that you as an employer actually verified somebody's eligibility to work if if some of these really core functional elements are missing? So those are substantive violations. And the way it works is these types of violations can trigger immediate fines in the event of a government inspection. They're not just paperwork imperfections. They're they're a big deal and so, those are those are the ones we care about the most. Right? Technical or procedural, that's the... On the right hand side of the slide, they live in a different category altogether. So they're more clerical in nature. Maybe you have a missing employee address in section one. Maybe the date of birth wasn't entered. A field was left incomplete but maybe you have a copy of the document. Those are the types of things that traditionally were considered technical and under the law and this is what you all answered the question for with with that poll under the law that was that came about in 1996 employers, for one of these technical violations if that's all that was on the form was a technical violation They must be provided ten business days to correct it before a fine can be issued which is great. Right? It's like, okay, I made a tiny mistake. No big deal. I'll fix it within those ten days after the government tells me to do so and I'll go on my merry way. So that's the way it used to work which is why the development that we're going to talk about today is getting so much attention. So let's get into it. And, as I mentioned that virtue memorandum has been around since 1997 and over the years ICE, you know, they had indicated well, we're gonna update this. Right? It's it's very old. It's it's you know, it's it's long in the tooth. We need to account for different things. The form has changed since 1996. Right? And so that guidance has finally arrived but it came through a very different channel than what we were expecting. Essentially what the government did is they simply updated this inspection fact sheet on their website and it was first updated in March of this year, which is why you see that 03/16/2026 date. Now, when we started reviewing this revised fact sheet, the first thing that really jumped out to us is they have inserted a lot more detail about what a substantive versus a technical violation was and that substantive list, remember those are the ones that are immediately finable and serious, it got a lot longer. Right? I mean, so before it used to be fairly balanced, now all of a sudden, the substantive was was, was taking the lead. Another interesting observation is the revised fact sheet, now breaks the substantive part more specifically section one, section two, the different supplements in the form, and they also include these broader process based failures within an employer's I-nine program. And we're going to talk about that in some detail. Finally, the agency did add some new technical or procedural violations to account for some of the the form changes that have happened over the the last decade or so. So this is the framework. Again, high level, you know, let's review form I nine. You can be penalized for errors and mistakes. We previously had this substantive and technical framework. Employers are typically provided ten business days for the technical, but now we have this policy change just this year that seems to be changing the structure of the substantive versus the technical. So let's look into how this is actually taking shape so far and I want to start a little bit with some of these process level. So on the left side of the... I'm going to show you the more traditional core substantive violations. These are not new. So what you see on the left here, not new. This is historically what is considered a substantive. I already covered it all a little bit, but I'll go over it again. So failure to prepare an I nine. Right? That's that's that's pretty big deal. Right? No I nine. This one also comes up which is good for, you know, helping your clients prepare for audits if they're unable to produce it and it's in at the in time of inspection. Maybe they have it but they just don't know where it is or they just can't get to it in time. That's a substantive violation or any really any kind of process where the government can't reasonably determine whether the verification process even occurred. Right? So those are all substantive, and they've existed for decades. On the right hand side, this shows the revised fact sheet now appears to more explicitly pull in certain process based failures into that category, as well. And so this is kind of what I think the government's broader view is that, you know, certain failures in the I nine process, really undermine the reliability of a verification system. So because of that, we want to incentivize employers to do a better job. And one that really stood out to us is electronic I nine compliance. And so this this concept is not new. Right? And so you all may be aware, of course, that employers can electronically generate and store and retain i-nine forms actually since early 2000s and the Department of Homeland Security has long maintained that if an employer does that you have to maintain certain requirements within that system. So you have to have audit trails, you have to have valid electronic signatures, you have to be able to retrieve it, there's certain security precautions, all of these things which we spend a lot of time on with our solution, to make sure that it meets these requirements, but all these requirements exist. And now in this policy, ICE is saying that when they review an electronic I nine system, if they find a serious error, they're going to consider it a substantive violation. And I think that really is important to remember. Again, if you're getting involved with I nine auditing, you're reviewing clients electronic i9s, there are a lot of different things which sometimes will be described as electronic i9s, but maybe aren't. Right? So you might see a simple fillable PDF that, you know doesn't necessarily... Doesn't have a handwritten signature on it, doesn't have any audit trails. I mean, you know, that could be a potentially concerning area. So electronic anon compliance, that's one area to keep a watch out on under this new guidance. Another is this virtual or alternative procedure process which you might also be familiar with. So since 2023, employers that participate in E Verify can remotely examine documents rather than doing a face to face meeting with a new hire employee but there are a variety of requirements that they have to follow if they choose to do that and what the government is saying now is well, if you don't follow some of that requirements, some of those requirements you could be assessed a fine. Right? And it could be considered a substantive violation. And so I again if you look at all of these really together I think the logic appears to be that the government's broader framework is we want to make sure this process is being conducted according to the rules that have been established. Another example, the Spanish language form I nine. You might be familiar with this. It's existed for a long time. They've always produced a Spanish version. They've always said, and it's still true, that it can only be used in Puerto Rico. So only can be completed in Puerto Rico, Peter, Puerto Rico. You can use it as a translation guide elsewhere, but you can't complete it anywhere else outside of Puerto Rico. In the past, this was always considered, well, if you did it that way, it's okay. It's a technical violation. You can fix it. Now they're describing it as a as a substantive violation. So again, these are really the high level kind of framework of of what the government is now viewing more seriously than they did before. And by the way, we haven't even gotten into the individual field level examples yet because that's where I think some of these reclassifications become even more noticeable. And again, if you're doing this type of auditing yourself and you're you're looking at, clients, I nines, I think these, these types of things can be very helpful. So let's actually begin that process and we'll start at the beginning, which is section one. So for those of you I'm sure are aware, section one is the is the the very first part of the four ninety nine which the employee completes, hopefully on or before their first day of work for pay. And what I've done on this slide is I've highlighted the specific section one fields that ICE now, classifies as substantive when missing. In some of these, if you'll notice, I think are fairly striking when you think about the historical framework. So date of birth. Traditionally, I would say most people have not viewed a missing date of birth as the kind of a mission that fundamentally undermines the verification process. Right? I mean, is it important? Absolutely. It helps to identify somebody but historically it's been treated as a technical or clerical error. But now it is falling into the substantive, violation arena. So that's, you know, something to be aware of. The other important change here involves some of the employee identification numbers associated with non citizen workers. Historically, there was a degree of flexibility reflected in the guidance. So for example, you you may not see this as often but, you know, somebody chooses that fourth box, alien authorized to work, they're required to present or provide, excuse me, provide either an I 94 or in what's referred to as an alien number And sometimes, again, if you're reviewing these forms, maybe that was missing. But, oh, I actually happen to have a copy of a document that the employee provided, and I can see that information. Well, that meant it was a technical violation, but no more. According to the government's latest guidance that can now actually be considered a substantive violation. Another one you might see from occasion would be a missing employee signature date. So maybe the employee signed but the date is missing. This again tends to show up if you're looking at somebody with, you know, a paper I nine. Like electronic systems generally would prevent that from happening to begin with. But historically, ICE has always treated that as, well, that's a technical issue, as long as, you know, there's some evidence that it was timely completed. But under this revised fact sheet, once again, now this is looking like a substantive violation. So these are some of the things again that have changed with respect to how you would evaluate and how an employer might be assessed fines relating to errors in this first part of the form. But we're just beginning because now we have to go to the second part. So section two, which again I'm sure many of you are familiar with, this is the part that an employer completes where they will enter some key information including whatever documentation the employee provides to prove their identity and work authorization. They'll also enter information about the job, the employer themselves, and we're going to continue that same trend, right? So where we're narrowing a lot of the flexibility. Again I've highlighted the fields that ICE that now appears to classify as substantive when they are missing and for for many of you out there who have dealt with auditing of, you know, paper I nines, legacy I nines, some of these I would suspect are gonna seem very familiar. Right? You've got a situation where it's clear that some sort of documentation were reviewed but maybe one of the fields was missed. Right? The issuing authority. That one always gets missed, or maybe even a document number in in some cases. And once again, historically, when... With those types of emissions, one of the first questions that I would ask, as as as counsel when I was representing clients was okay, but do we have copies of the employee's documents? Right? Sometimes the employer would just choose to make copies that's entirely within their right to do so. And if they did, that was great because we could fill in the gaps and it was treated as a technical violation. But once again, under this revised fact sheet, that flexibility appears to be gone. Right? Robert actually mentioned it at the start in terms of retaining photocopies and and the like. So now ICE appears to classify these emissions as substantive, makes no mention of document copies at all. So I think that's important. Moving on down the line, we have the first day of employment and anybody who has... Especially for a certain era of form I nines, if you've reviewed this, you've you've seen that in... For many versions of the form I nines, some of the older ones, the first day of of employment was literally in the middle of a paragraph of text. I mean, as far as form design concerns, it was maybe not the best. And so we're very used to seeing missing start dates. And in the... Historically, that was treated as a technical violation. Okay. That's fine. You missed it, but you can add it later. Once again, this is now treated as a substantive violation under this new policy. We also see this, alternative procedure checkbox. Alternative procedure is what we refer to as that remote document inspection, also known as the virtual process. Here they're saying if that wasn't checked and you actually used it, that's a substantive violation. We also have another really important thing relating to the receipt rule, which you may be familiar with. So under the receipt rule, an employee can provide a receipt for a lost, stolen, or damaged document. And if they do so, you as an employer, for example, or if you're looking at an employer's I nine, you essentially take ninety days from their start date and within that ninety day period they need to present you a replacement document or some other alternate documentation. Now they are saying if you don't follow-up with that process, that will be treated, as a substantive violation as well. And so, again, if I'm looking at this like holistically or just kind of from from afar, I would say the government really is trying to focus more on the entire verification process itself, making sure that it's carried out correctly from beginning to end. And if there are any gaps in that process whatsoever, they seem to be considering that a serious violation. And what's interesting is some of those gaps may not even necessarily lead to the hiring of an unauthorized, worker, which is really where I think the stakes, have been increased for employers. But let's, let's finish the form and then we'll discuss some other elements as well. So right now we've gone through really the the heart of it. Right? Sections one and two, that's probably where you spend a lot of your time if you're reviewing and auditing, forms for for your for your clients. But you also have this thing called supplement a, which you may or may not have seen. It used to actually just be part of section one all the way at the bottom, but this is referred to as the preparer translator certification. Right? So if a new hire requires some help, they need some assistance, or they need some, interpretation, some translation, whoever assists with that process has to, complete, that... This portion of the form which is now supplement a. Once again, historically, if you had, you know, something that was missing, it was generally viewed as a minor issue. It was technical. Right? Maybe they could they could still tell that someone had assisted the form because maybe certain portions are completed. Maybe a box was checked. There was some evidence but once again now under this revised fact sheet, if any of these fields are missing and a preparer and or translator was used, that is now a serious violation that you would need to investigate and note. So you know again just something to keep in mind this this is probably not the area that's going to keep your clients up at night but I think it's just another example of how broadly this policy now appears to extend. Final part of the form that we're going to go into in detail, this is known as supplement b. It's an important section within the form I nine world because it can be used for multiple reasons. For many years, if you're wondering what the heck is supplement be, for many years it was referred to as section three. They, you know, kind of reorganized the form and so now it's a supplement but it really serves essentially the same purpose. It can be used for reverification of temporary work authorization. Let's say you have somebody here on a visa or they have an EAD, a work permit, those types of things generally. It can be used for rehires within an allowable three year period so you don't have to complete the whole form all over again and in some situations it's used just for updates like somebody has a legal name change and you decide you want to record it you can use supplement b. And what we see here, again, same same construct, I've highlighted the areas, is they're kind of... ICE is following the same, direction that they did with section two. So for example, if supplement b is used for that rehire and for some reason the rehire date is missing that is now going to be classified as a substantive violation. Similarly if supplement b is being used for reverification and somebody has to show you know, documentation. Right? But those details were missing and you have a copy. Well, nope. Still gonna be treated, as substantive violation. We also continue to see some of the newer process oriented concepts carry forward here as well. So if you're, you can also use the alternative procedure remote document examination for reverification. But if you don't check that box, well, that's another substantive violation. If you don't follow-up with a receipt, another substantive violation. So you can kind of get a sense by now, I think, the tightening of the rules, apply across initial verification, reverification, rehire workflows. So really the entirety of the process. And now I would say since we've summarized the scope and I hopefully you've gotten your arms a little bit about around this a bit more it seems like a perfect time Robert for another polling question. I think that's great, John. And just a lot of details, a lot of information there. I'm really happy that there's a slide deck handout that you all can get to, just that covers all that ground. But thank you, John. A lot of details. So now we've got another poll for you. It's our second poll now. You'll see your pop up on the left, and then you'll also see a little poll column with a red dot come out on the right. So you should see that opening. So go ahead and click that and mark your response and click the submit button. Which of the following is now a substantive violation? You can choose only one. Which of the following is now a substantive form I nine violation? Is it a, missing the employee's first day of employment in section two? Is it b, failing to record other last names used? Is it c, using the incorrect form I nine version, or is it d, completing the form in purple glitter pen? We know, the wrong the wrong pen, the wrong pencil can sometimes lead to trouble there. Is it sub... Substantive? I'm not sure. So once again, click that poll button. It'll be on the right side where we have q and a and we have docs. There'll be a little red dot on it. Go ahead and click that. Click your answer and hit submit. Which of the following is now substantive form violation? Missing employees, first day of employment. Vast majority, of our audience got that one, John. Is that, is that the correct answer? You know, I have to say, that glitter pan option, you know, it's pretty it's pretty to look at but you might have a mess later on. So I'm... Yeah, I really want to say that but no, that is that is the correct answer. Everyone, that shows that is absolutely correct. It is that first day of employment, which is surprising because it seems seems rather technical, but it is now Very good. substantive. Thank you, everyone. Absolutely. Alright. Well, thank you all, for participating in that. And now I think it's time to move to another interesting area of this policy. We've been talking, of course, about substantive violations a lot. You're probably tired of hearing me use that term, but really what it is, it's it's it's serious violations. It's things that your clients are going to be concerned about and and perhaps you can help them identify them. But we can't forget there was also the technical violations. They they still exist. Maybe they've gotten much smaller, but they still exist. And as it turns out the revised fact sheet articulates some new ones as well. So they're still there and so let's go through them and the way that I've organized them just for clarity is identity, integrity and program integrity and so we'll start with the identity ones first and so one of the newly listed technical violations is that we just saw it in the last poll, failure to record the other last names used by the employee. This one for those of you who are familiar with it may not be a huge surprise. So years ago the form used to ask for main name. Under historical guidance, omission of a maiden name was already generally considered a technical violation. Of course, over time, the form has broadened that concept into other last names used. That obviously captures more than just marriage related name changes so you know this one not very dramatic policy shift really just about you know modernizing the terminology but it's good to keep in mind so if somebody does have another last name used it should be fixed but again it's technical it's it's a little bit more minor minor. Excuse me. We also see here a new technical violation involving failure to record an employee's updated name in supplement b. So again this tends to arise, I would say, more in rehire situations when an employee's legal name may have, you know, changed over time. And then we have, I think, what what a very paper world, specific type of error. So failure to include the employee's complete name at the top of page two, supplement a or supplement b. So, again, if you've worked with inines long enough, you might know for a period of time, there were two pages and there was always this concern, well, gee, what happens if the pages get separated and we can't tell who this second page is for? At the very top, it would require you to write the employee's name and citizenship status and so again ICE is just kind of you know updating their guidance and say well if you have one of those and the employee name is missing we consider that technical we can we can you know we can point it out to you but you do have the opportunity to to correct. So that's the one side of the coin. The other is what I'm referring to as program integrity and the first example which again we just used in the poll was failure to use the correct version or version of the four ninety nine at the time of completion. This one I would think is I would say is also widely understood operationally and historically. So again relatively straight forward this is a technical violation. What the government has said is you can fix this by attaching an explanation to the form. That's one easy way of saying okay we recognize this was the wrong version and we're just you know we filled it out nevertheless in good faith. So but the really interesting one for me on this slide at least involves social security numbers for everify participants. So the revised fact sheet now specifically identifies failure to ensure that the social security number is correct, not just missing but correct, as a technical violation for E Verify employers. And so if you have clients out there that are using E Verify you probably know the Social Security number is is required. Of course, you can complete the I9 if the person doesn't have a social but they've applied for one. But at the end of the day, you need it because that's how E Verify primarily works is looking up that social. And if you, you know, the client, I should say, your employer client hasn't been good about making sure that those number is is accurate, then, you couldn't face a technical violation. So, again, it's kind of new. It's kind of interesting. It is, by the way, one of the benefits of using, like an electronic dining solution like we provide because whatever the employee puts for that social is just automatically going to get sent to you verify but nevertheless something to be aware of. So now now that we've discussed, all of these different types of things that have changed, a lot of change as Robert said, I recognize this is a lot of information but I just I couldn't help it. Right? I get excited about this because there's so much, that I think is is worthwhile knowing. But now I want to cover something that I think is equally important and that is what hasn't changed. And this is probably, I think something that you might actually consider really the silver lining, in what might otherwise feel a very heavy conversation because despite all the changes we just walked through, that underlying good faith remediation framework that I mentioned at the top of the hour, nothing in the statute has changed long standing concepts involving remediation, mitigation, good faith efforts, all of the things, all of the reasons why you would audit a client's finance to begin with, they all still exist. And I think that's important because, if your clients are aware of this policy change, you know, there might be this tendency to say, well, wait a second. Right? All of these are just immediately finable. You know, what's the value of correcting anything? And the answer I would say is potentially quite a bit. Right? So first, there's the practical and legal concept of good faith itself. So the immigration statute references it repeatedly and historically both ICE as an agency and the courts have recognized a meaningful distinction between employers that proactively review and correct their problems versus employers that just, you know, throw up their hands and say, well, we'll just let it be. So practically speaking employ... When an employer, you know, hires you, for example, to conduct an internal audit, to review records, you know, and they spend time, they spend resources to... You know, correcting deficiencies, maybe they're updating their processes, maybe they're retraining staff, whatever they're doing to improve their compliance, that creates a very different narrative, during an ICE inspection than an employer that made no effort whatsoever. And so historically and even after this policy change, we have seen ICE repeatedly indicate that employers are encouraged to make corrections before that ICE inspection occurs. Now that doesn't mean that, you know, every corrected error is just gonna magically, absolve the employer of all potential liabilities. Right? I mean, that's not the point but but ICE has considerable discretion in how those inspections are resolved. There are absolutely situations where employers had violations that were finable yet ICE still exercised discretion, issued warning notices rather than financial penalties because of that good faith effort that the employer, actually, you know, exercised. The second point, I would emphasize is around mitigation. So even when fines are assessed, good faith remediate... Mediation efforts may still support fine reductions. So under again under the statute there's there's this mechanism that allows the government to either enhance or mitigate fines and one of the ways that you mitigate is if an employer, showed good faith. So depending on the size of the inspection, the overall exposure involved, you know, even like a relatively modest percentage reduction can become financially meaningful and I think is worthwhile. And then there's one kind of final concept that I think is again incredibly important doesn't get discussed all that much and that is the statute of limitations. If you're familiar with that kind of notion, you know, in law that there's some period of time beyond which we should not hold a party responsible and in the concept of i9s there is actually a five year statute of limitation that applies in this area but for defective I-9s that five year period does not begin to run until the violation is corrected or you know the retention obligation expires. So what that means is if you wanna get... Take advantage of that five year period, you need to make corrections. Right? You need to actually take some efforts. So, again, when you put all this together, you know, I think the takeaway is not, okay, let's throw up our hands because everything is serious or substantive. It's that proactive remediation correction efforts can still carry a significant value even within this kind of new enforcement environment that we we find ourselves in. And with that Robert, I'll hand it back to you for yet another polling question. Thank you, John. So we're at our third poll now. You'll all see it come up. There'll be the little pop up with a blue pop up on your lower left. And on the right side, next to docs, next to q and a, a poll button will come up. And you would just click on there, Go ahead, mark your answer, and click submit. So now we're locked... Talking about technical violations. Which of the following is now identified as a newly added technical violation? A, missing the employee's date of birth in section one, b, missing document details in section two, c, using the incorrect version of form I nine at the time of completion. And I've seen some questions come in around these form I nines and when they were updated and how to get the latest one. And then finally, d, filing the I nine form under, I'll deal with this later. I think we all have that pile. So not... Newly identified as a technical violation, missing employee's date of birth in section one, missing document details in section two, using the incorrect version of form I nine at the time of completion, or filing the I nine under I'll deal with this later. And what do we have not using? The incorrect version of the form is far and away our most popular answer here, John, on what is a newly added technical violation. I feel like we've got a pretty smart audience here. How'd they do on this one? Open. We lost John real quick. Oh, and he's back. Very back. Apologies for that. Excellent. Yes. So this one is the incorrect version of the form I nine at the time of completion. It is a technical. language. Perfect. Well done, everyone. And once again, I wanna remind you all, there's a printout of... There's a PDF available of all these slides in the docs tab, on the right side because John Fay Fay's covering a lot of ground here, which is great. I really appreciate you, John Fay. So why don't. you bring us home? Yes. I will indeed. So here we are. This is... This last slide here should hopefully bring all of this together, into what I hope will feel like a practical and actionable, strategy for you and your clients. I do wanna emphasize, by the way, there's no single universal I nine strategy that works perfectly, for everyone. Right? But we... But we... But when we take a step back and we look at the changes that I've discussed today I think there are some broader areas that deserve attention just from a risk and remediation standpoint and the first one is is really focusing on the areas that present the greatest potential risk of exposure. This has always been a good idea in the i9 auditing world. I think it becomes even more important today and so for many organizations maybe paper and legacy i9s they might represent kind of the biggest potential risk. Right? You might find things like missing dates, missing document details, missing start dates, right, incomplete fields. Some of these, as we discussed were previously technical. Many of them now are instead substantive. So from a practical standpoint, employers, and you might be... Want to start by identifying where those newly classified substantive violations are most likely to exist within their environment. The second area I would recommend involves workflows. So, if we think about some of the process level changes and the process level errors that the government is now thinking about, you know, those are things like virtual remote document examination. Right, I mean do we know what we're doing there? Are we following the correct procedures? Receipts for lost stolen or damaged document? Are we following through with that process? Are we making sure that after a ninety day period the employee presents some the replacement document or something else that's acceptable? You know, the the government now appears to be focusing on that, very very clearly. The third area that I would recommend is prioritization. Right? So not every issue maybe carries the same level of exposure. We talked about missing I nines. Those those have always been really the top of the list, but you might have reverification failures. You might have electronic. You might have clients out there who think they're using electronic I9s or maybe they're not using a compliant one because it doesn't have audit trails, you know those types of things and once you start identifying those, those are the ones that typically you know in many instances make sense to address first and then finally you know if employers are conducting remediation efforts after you've you know helped them identify things I think consistency and documentation becomes very important. Right? I mean, track what was reviewed, what was corrected, make sure to apply your remediation approaches, how you're fixing them, consistently across the organization. Fortunately, I should say there are now electronic tools to assist with this. So at Equifax, we offer a solution called I nine inspect, which will ingest and analyze historical I nines. It'll help spot potential errors. It'll assist with some of that I nine correction. This can be, you know, useful for employers with, like, hundreds or even thousands of I nines. Right? Because it's a lot to review. And then finally, I'll mention one additional resource here. You can see it on your slide. The Department of Justice and ICE issued this joint guidance on conducting internal audits. It was it was many years ago, but it's still one of the better practical resources from the government, particularly for auditors because it talks about some of these things, it talks about correction efforts and thinking about it, thoughtfully, and consistently. So again, I think the the key takeaway here from all of this I hope for you is don't panic. Right? You know, spend some time thinking about with your clients, you know, where their I nine risk may lie, if at all. Help them prioritize appropriately, and then think about how you're going to correct, right, strategically rather than reactively. And with that, I'll hand it back over to Robert for more information on how we can help. Thanks, John. Appreciate that. And I do wanna dive in for a quick moment on how we solve for this with Paychex Flex, our all in one HCM platform. So if you have clients who are on Flex, there's a form I nine test that's already built in. It's part of the new hire process. There's even an option for remote form I nine completion for a fee available through our partnership with Equifax. So existing Paychex clients already have access to this within the Paychex Flex platform. Now you and your clients may already work with an HR business partner as well. If you do, we encourage you to reach out to them directly for support and guidance. Now if you wanna learn more about how a dedicated HRBP can help you and your clients address compliance concerns like this, we encourage you to click yes on the next poll to speak with one of our Paychex experts. And you can also click yes if you or your clients are still juggling payroll, HR, and compliance tasks on your own and would like to explore how Paychex Flex and Paychex could provide advantages like this for any new business. So I quickly just wanted to go over what we covered today. It was a lot of ground. I wanna thank John Fay again. We covered then and now about I nine error classifications. What hasn't changed, which is that good faith framework, the proactive HR steps that you and your clients should be considering. And now we wanna get to that final poll question here. This is the fourth poll of the day. Once again, you'll see that pop up come up. You'll see the tab open up next to docs in q and a. And I just want you to mark your response, yes or no, click respond, then click submit. Would you like to speak with a Paychex team member about HR guidance or compliance support? We know every firm is different. We know every customer is different. Every business is different. Every one of your clients is different. That's why we'd like you to talk to an expert and see what the right solution will be for you and for your team. So let's grab some of those questions you've submitted. A lot of questions have come in. I really appreciate all the interest around this topic. It really can be complicated and a certain way to bulk up your CAS practice if you're a firm here. So something that came in here was how concerned should we be about the older paper I nines for employees hired many years ago? We know a lot of small businesses have been around. They're family businesses, John. There's probably I nines from decades ago in personnel files somewhere. How concerned should should, our clients be about that? Yeah, so I guess I would say they deserve thoughtful attention primarily because of the fact that you know I nine has always been known as one of the most potentially error ridden form out there. There was not a lot of guidance for many years. We see a lot of employers. There's different types of roles that will be completing I-9s. It's very easy to miss something depending upon where the where the the form or the field was located. Basically, they're they're more vulnerable to human, omit, omission. Right? So from a risk prioritization standpoint, if you have clients with paper I nines, I would really focus on those paper records first. Again, keeping in mind some of these new, policy guidances that we've seen. Perfect. It fits right into that, that priority order you pet... Put put out as you get into auditing where you're at and helping your clients audit where they are at. And this question plays right into that. If an employer identifies newly substantive errors during an internal audit, would you generally recommend correcting them now even though they may already be finable? So I've already messed up. How do I handle this? Yeah. And and really, it it... That that is the good faith nature. So generally speaking, we would always recommend, you know, even if you know, gosh, you know, under the... Under this guidance, they they got me dead to rights, but but still there's value in it because you wanna show that good faith effort. In addition, as I briefly mentioned, there's this five year statute of limitations. So if the client is able to fix those errors and then they don't get audited for another five years, they would have a defense in the event of a potential fine. So we always say whenever possible correction is usually the way to go. Very good. And I've, we're running up against time here. So I just got one last question. Do these changes affect electronic I nine systems differently than paper processes? Are are these two are these two things different, or are they really just the same and they're just executed via different vehicles? Yeah. I I would say in some ways, yes, for sure because, what we've seen... Obviously, if an electronic system has, you know, any kind of error in it that leads to an emission, then really the guidance kind of affects the same way. But what we saw today and then what I hope, people took away from is that ICE is now looking at really process level failures. They know there are all of these rules around electronic I nines, that employers may not necessarily see like audit trails and electronic signature and the like. And so, really, what this guidance says is those things are important, and employers do need to do their their due diligence and think about them when they're reviewing their records. That's great. Well, I would say that wraps up our q and a, but I wanna thank everybody, for entering all those questions. I'm seeing them coming in. There's just a lot of great details there, and I could see we could be putting on event like this again, in the near future. So thank you again, John, for all that practical guidance on these very timely issues. I really appreciate you. My pleasure. And I appreciate our audience, all of these accounting professionals and your clients, you've got a lot to understand, a lot to address as you're developing your CAS practice. I could see this being just a really helpful area where your clients could really use your help and your expertise. Now as a reminder, you can find an array of resources related to today's topic in the docs column at the right along with a printable PDF of the slide deck. We also have a handy FAQ sheet with multiple links to the various government resources that John mentioned, including some of those cited on this list. There are also handouts on our form I nine and e verify service, organizing a self audit to ensure documents for you and your clients are up to spec, and more. And you can also follow John on LinkedIn via his link in the slide deck. Now if you haven't yet completed the brief survey that launched previously, we encourage you to complete that now before we close. We value and appreciate your feedback as your response helps us improve future resources like this to support you and your clients. And now I want to thank you all for joining us today for Preventing Penalty Risks, Preparing Your Clients for New I-nine Error Rules. Now provided you met both polling and connection time requirements for CPE credit today, you'll receive a separate email within a few hours of the close of this webinar. There'll be a link to download your CPE certificate. Now if you did not meet eligibility requirements easy for me to say you will not receive that separate email. Paychex will also be sending all registrants a follow-up email within one business day with a link to access the on demand recording and related resources. But as a reminder, the on demand recordings are not eligible for CPE credit, but they're certainly gonna be very useful as you start to take this expertise and this information out to your clients. Now if you'd like to review the needs of your practice with a Paychex rep, you can click on the talk with our team button there at the top of the right of your screen to request a free consultation. As always, our goal is to serve as a leader in helping you and your clients understand new information and to best maximize advisory opportunities for your firm. I wanna thank you again, and I hope everyone has a great day.